2024 Best Fleet Value in America Winners List

VINCENTRIC BEST FLEET VALUE IN AMERICA

Once per year Vincentric performs a cost of ownership analysis based upon typical use in commercial fleet to determine the Vincentric Best Fleet Value in America™ Awards. Vincentric measures cost-of-ownership using eight different cost factors: depreciation, fees & taxes, financing, fuel, insurance, maintenance, opportunity cost, and repairs. Each vehicle was evaluated in all 50 states plus DC using 28 different ownership/mileage scenarios. Winners were identified by determining which vehicles had the lowest fleet lifecycle cost in the most scenarios for its segment. A full list of winners is shown below.

Defining Value – Learn more about how Vincentric defines value for the fleet market.

Press Release – Read the full press release announcing the 2024 Vincentric Best Fleet Value in America Awards.

2024 AWARD WINNERS
PASSENGER CAR
Subcompact		Mini Cooper Electric SE Contributing factors: Won all 28 lifecycle cost scenarios Lowest Fuel Cost in its Class Lowest Maintenance Cost in its Class Lowest Operating Costs in its Class Outperformed 12 Competitor Trims
Subcompact
Compact		Toyota Corolla Hybrid LE Contributing factors: Won all 28 lifecycle cost scenarios Lowest Depreciation Cost in its Class Outperformed 25 Competitor Trims
Compact
Compact Hatchback		Toyota Prius Prime SE Contributing factors: Won 14 of 28 lifecycle cost scenarios Lowest Insurance Cost in its Class Outperformed 21 Competitor Trims
Compact Hatchback
Mid-Size		Toyota Camry Hybrid LE Contributing factors: Won 21 of 28 lifecycle cost scenarios Outperformed 34 Competitor Trims
Mid-Size
LUXURY CAR
Luxury Compact		Tesla Model 3 Standard Range RWD Contributing factors: Won 21 of 28 lifecycle cost scenarios Lowest Maintenance Cost in its Class Lowest Operating Costs in its Class Outperformed 22 Competitor Trims
Luxury Compact
Luxury Mid-Size Sedan		BMW i4 eDrive35 Contributing factors: Won 16 of 28 lifecycle cost scenarios Lowest Fuel Cost in its Class Outperformed 60 Competitor Trims
Luxury Mid-Size Sedan
Luxury Large Sedan		Volvo S90 Plug-In Hybrid T8 Plus eAWD Contributing factors: Won 18 of 28 lifecycle cost scenarios Outperformed 21 Competitor Trims
Luxury Large Sedan
Luxury Wagon		Audi A4 Allroad Premium 45 2.0T Contributing factors: Won 16 of 28 lifecycle cost scenarios Lowest Depreciation Cost in its Class Outperformed 6 Competitor Trims
Luxury Wagon
SUV
Subcompact SUV		Hyundai Kona Electric SEL FWD Contributing factors: Won 11 of 28 lifecycle cost scenarios Lowest Fuel Cost in its Class Lowest Operating Costs in its Class Outperformed 42 Competitor Trims
Subcompact SUV
Compact SUV		Subaru Crosstrek Base Contributing factors: Won 23 of 28 lifecycle cost scenarios Lowest Depreciation Cost in its Class Lowest Insurance Cost in its Class Outperformed 233 Competitor Trims
Compact SUV
Mid-Size SUV		Subaru Outback Base Contributing factors: Won all 28 lifecycle cost scenarios Lowest Depreciation Cost in its Class Lowest Insurance Cost in its Class Outperformed 216 Competitor Trims
Mid-Size SUV
Large SUV		Dodge Durango SXT RWD Contributing factors: Won 15 of 28 lifecycle cost scenarios Lowest Depreciation Cost in its Class Lowest Operating Costs in its Class Outperformed 74 Competitor Trims
Large SUV
LUXURY SUV
Luxury Compact SUV		Tesla Model Y Long Range AWD Contributing factors: Won 17 of 28 lifecycle cost scenarios Lowest Fuel Cost in its Class Lowest Maintenance Cost in its Class Outperformed 96 Competitor Trims
Luxury Compact SUV
Luxury Mid-Size SUV		Cadillac Lyriq Tech Contributing factors: Won all 28 lifecycle cost scenarios Outperformed 79 Competitor Trims
Luxury Mid-Size SUV
Luxury Large SUV		Infiniti QX60 Pure FWD Contributing factors: Won all 28 lifecycle cost scenarios Lowest Depreciation Cost in its Class Lowest Repair Cost in its Class Outperformed 48 Competitor Trims
Luxury Large SUV
TRUCK
Small Pickup		Ford Maverick XL Supercrew FWD Contributing factors: Won 15 of 28 lifecycle cost scenarios Lowest Fixed Costs in its Class Outperformed 56 Competitor Trims
Small Pickup
Full-Size 1/2-Ton Pickup		Ford F-150 Lightning Pro Supercrew 4WD Contributing factors: Won 22 of 28 lifecycle cost scenarios Outperformed 241 Competitor Trims
Full-Size 1/2-Ton Pickup
Full-Size 3/4-Ton Pickup		Ford F-250 XL Reg Cab 2WD Contributing factors: Won 19 of 28 lifecycle cost scenarios Lowest Insurance Cost in its Class Outperformed 167 Competitor Trims
Full-Size 3/4-Ton Pickup
Full-Size 1-Ton Pickup		Ford F-350 XL Reg Cab 2WD SRW Contributing factors: Won 21 of 28 lifecycle cost scenarios Lowest Insurance Cost in its Class Outperformed 218 Competitor Trims
Full-Size 1-Ton Pickup
VAN
Minivan		Toyota Sienna LE Contributing factors: Won all 28 lifecycle cost scenarios Lowest Depreciation Cost in its Class Outperformed 15 Competitor Trims
Minivan
Full-Size 3/4-Ton Passenger Van		GMC Savana G2500 6.6L V8 SWB Contributing factors: Won 13 of 28 lifecycle cost scenarios Lowest Repair Cost in its Class Outperformed 10 Competitor Trims
Full-Size 3/4-Ton Passenger Van
Full-Size 1-Ton Passenger Van		Ford T350 Vans XLT Low Roof RWD 148 Contributing factors: Won 16 of 28 lifecycle cost scenarios Lowest Depreciation Cost in its Class Lowest Maintenance Cost in its CLass Outperformed 8 Competitor Trims
Full-Size 1-Ton Passenger Van
Full-Size 1/2-Ton Cargo Van		Ford T150 Vans Cargo Low Roof RWD 130 Contributing factors: Won 18 of 28 lifecycle cost scenarios Lowest Depreciation Cost in its Class Lowest Insurance Cost in its Class Lowest Maintenance Cost in its Class Outperformed 10 Competitor Trims
Full-Size 1/2-Ton Cargo Van
Full-Size 3/4-Ton Cargo Van		Ford T250 Vans Cargo Low Roof RWD 130 Contributing factors: Won 23 of 28 lifecycle cost scenarios Lowest Depreciation Cost in its Class Lowest Repair Cost in its Class Outperformed 42 Competitor Trims
Full-Size 3/4-Ton Cargo Van
Full-Size 1-Ton Cargo Van		Ford E-Transit 350 Base Cargo LR 130 WB Contributing factors: Won 12 of 28 lifecycle cost scenarios Lowest Maintenance Cost in its Class Lowest Operating Costs in its Class Outperformed 49 Competitor Trims
Full-Size 1-Ton Cargo Van
Images shown may not reflect the specific trim level of the winning vehicle.
<Back to Vincentric Best Value in America Awards